Menu Close

Silmarillion Awards – Winner of the Wisest Counselor Silmaril



Me: Hello, everyone, and welcome to the final phase of the 2017 Silmarillion Awards! It has been a rollicking adventure indeed, and we can’t thank you enough for your enthusiasm and participation this year. To kick it off, I’d like to welcome up a very special character from Middle Earth to present the award for Wisest Counselor. *peeks over shoulder* Um, a very special character from Middle Earth. *clears throat* A certain wise counselor . . . to present . . . Ahem, it appears our presenter has yet to arrive–

*a pointy grey hat pokes out from backstage*

Gandalf: Not so, you fool! *strides onto stage and snatches mic* A wizard is never late, nor is he early. He arrives precisely when he intends to. I was merely arranging celebratory provisions for later.

Me: Apologies, Gandalf. We’re just happy to have you here. My friends, allow me to introduce Gandalf the Grey, also known as Mithrandir, the White Rider, Greyhame, and Stormcrow, among other names. He is certainly the wisest counselor anyone could meet in Middle Earth. *bows and exits stage*

Gandalf: Thank you. Now then. Where were we? Ah, yes, the time has come to award the Wisest Counselor Silmaril to the character deemed most worthy by all of you. *sniffs* You’re a much nicer audience than I find in Hobbiton, did you know? Taller, yes, but rather less noisy.

Ahem. Five characters of great wisdom contended for this Silmaril, but only one may receive it. And the fellow who secured the most votes is deserving indeed. I shouldn’t be surprised, really, but even the very wise cannot see all ends.

The counsel this gentleman has provided his friends has most certainly changed the courses of their lives, and perhaps even saved some. Like I always say, all we have to decide is what to do with the time that has been given us, and this man has decided to do a great deal of good with his. He knows that it is not our part to master all the tides of the world. Instead, he pours all of his strength and considerable heart into guiding the tides under his control, and surrendering the rest to his Master.

Though he has walked through times of sorrow and seasons of waiting, he has stayed the course. He is a beacon of light to those who follow in his footsteps. Others may claim the title of hero in his tale, but if not for him, the road would have taken a very different turn indeed.

My friends, may I present the winner of the 2017 Wisest Counselor Silmaril:

Professor Charles Hamilton!

*a smartly dressed older gentleman with wild grey hair rises from the front row and joins Gandalf on stage*
Professor Hamilton: *in a British accent* My, your fireworks get better every year, Gandalf.
Gandalf: I should say they do. Congratulations, young man. *hands over the Silmaril* This is yours to keep for a lifetime.
Professor Hamilton: Young? *smiles* Compared to you, perhaps. I am honored to receive such a prize, though I must that any wisdom I possess is thanks to the very Source of all wisdom. I merely listen to Him.
Gandalf: And that is precisely what makes you wise. Now, before we acknowledge the runners-up, I would like to take a moment to honor you, Professor, by calling up a scene from your past. *waves staff*
*translucent image appears over the stage*

The professor grasped [Excalibur] and limped toward the central pedestal. He knelt at Bonnie’s side and placed the sword in Billy’s hands, wrapping his own fingers on top and elevating the blade. Billy opened his eyes and tightened his grasp on the hilt.

“William,” the professor said, softly, “what now is your weapon?”

Bonnie could see Billy’s eyes reflecting the professor’s shining face, enhanced by Excalibur’s glow. She held her breath, waiting for Billy’s reply.

“Truth,” he whispered, his voice rasping. “Truth is my sword.”

The professor nodded, his eyes now flashing, and his voice erupted in deep, echoing tones as if Billy’s answer strengthened him. “And what now is your defense?”

Color returned to Billy’s face, and his jaw tightened. His voice surged with emotion. “Faith . . . faith is my shield.”

*image fades*
Professor Hamilton: *blinks back tears and beams at a row of young people in the audience* How well I remember that day.
Gandalf: As I thought. It was a turning point for one of your young charges. For using your wisdom to strengthen weary bones and direct wandering hearts, ladies and gentleman, I present to you Professor Hamilton!
*thunderous applause*
Professor Hamilton: *bows, then leans over to whisper* By the way, it is an honor to meet the namesake of a certain cat.
*sounds of a scuffle*
*a cat yowls and streaks away between chairs*
Someone in the audience: Walter! I told you to hang onto him!
*chuckling, the professor takes a seat*
Gandalf: I cannot forget the wisdom of four other magnificent characters, and I thought it might interest all of you to find out how they fared in the voting round. *pulls scroll out of his robe and consults a list*
Professor Hamilton from Dragons in Our Midst – 34%
Puddleglum from The Chronicles of Narnia – 23%
Albus Dumbledore from Harry Potter – 21%
Prince of Farthestshore/Aethelbald from Tales of Goldstone Wood – 18%
Beana from Tales of Goldstone Wood – 4%
*a marsh-wiggle, wizard, prince, and goat incline their heads respectfully from the front row*

Gandalf: To all who did not win this year, I will not say do not weep, for not all tears are an evil. You have all performed admirably. Once again, congratulations to the dear professor. *looks around* Now . . . what am I supposed to do? Just–leave? Introduce someone?
Me: *hurries back out* Not to worry, I’ve got it. Thank you, Gandalf! Make sure to follow along with the presentations, everyone. Tomorrow the winner of the Least Competent Henchman will be announced, an event you certainly won’t want to miss. Happy Silmarillion Awards 2017!
[Note: excerpt taken from The Candlestone by Bryan Davis]

EDIT: For your convenience, here are the links to the award presentations! (Will be updated as they are posted.)
Most Magnificent Dragon
Most Loyal Friend
Most Nefarious Villain

43 Comments

  1. DJ Edwardson

    That was brilliant! You managed to weave in so many wonderful Gandalf quotes. And that flashback scene was a clever idea. I haven't read Dragons in Our Midst, but if Professor Hamilton is in it, it sound like I will have to.

    Thanks for such a wonderful award presentation!

    • admin

      Thanks so much, DJ! I thought a flashback of sorts would be appropriate, both as a fond memory for old fans and as a point of interest for new readers, because I try to convert as many people as possible into DIOM fans! ;D

      Thank YOU! Can't wait for yours too! I'm so excited to see which dragon outmatched all the rest…

    • admin

      Hamilton was my first pick, and Aethelbald a VERY close second! So excited to see a Bryan Davis character get some recognition. ^_^

  2. Jenelle

    Hooray, the ceremonies have officially begun!!!

    Loved this post, and even though I have no familiarity with the Professor, your post has definitely put his books up at the top of my reading list!

    Such a wonderful tribute to dear Gandalf, as well!

    • admin

      I feel so honored to start it off, and I can't wait to read all the other winner posts!

      Awww, thank you! I'll just casually slide the first book your way on Goodreads… 😉 If you like dragons, Arthurian legend, urban fantasy, witty quips, and some heartfelt hero's journeys, then you'll love Dragons in Our Midst! (Wow. I feel like a commercial. Not ashamed, though. XD)

      Thanks again!

  3. Lisa

    Yes that was so cool. And this whole process of Silmarillion Awards was fabuloys I had a lot of fun. I don't know the Professor unfortunately but he sure deserves my attention when I finally get into this series!

    • admin

      I'm so glad you've enjoyed it, Lisa! I've been having so much fun with it too. Oh yes, yes, yes! Read Dragons in Our Midst! It was one of the first series to get me hooked on fantasy. within those pages that I fell in love with dragons, and realized what an impact a blend of faith and fiction could make. <3

    • Daisy Phinney

      It is! Once you read the first book you'll be hungry for all the other books in the series and connected to the series! 🙂 It's a very recommendable book series!Bryan Davis does a wonderful job at storytelling.

    • admin

      Haha, what Daisy said! 🙂 And the series just keeps getting better with each book, so even if the first instalment doesn't fully convince you–KEEP READING. Circles of Seven (book 3) is one my absolute favorites.

  4. Christine Smith

    *screeches excitedly* OUR DEAR PROFESSOR WON!!!!! I'M SO HAPPY! (Also, The Candlestone quote made me want to reread those books all over again. I've been missing those precious characters lately!)

    This ceremony was BRILLIANT. The Gandalf quotes, him being "late" (but not really, obviously, since he CAN'T be late ;D), the fireworks, EVERYTHING. And then Gandalf the CAT. OHMYGRACIOUSGOODNESS. I died. You are amazing, Tracey! This was the best!

    • admin

      ME TOO! I LOVE PROF SO MUCH. Oh goodness, I've been wanting to reread them for the longest time. I actually have ambitious plans to read all 12 books from the three series back to back one day. XD

      Awww, thank you, Christine! (Of course, he's NEVER late. Neither am I… *cough* ;D) I couldn't NOT include Billy's cat, LOL! I remember reading about him and wondering, "What kind of a name is Gandalf for a cat?" That was obviously during my pre-LOTR days. XD

  5. Daisy Phinney

    Brilliant! I'm so glad the Prof won. I was just reading about him today and Merlin. (Oracles and Dragons in our Midst). He, Sapphira Adi, and Shiloh Nathanson are at the top three for me.

    • admin

      I was delighted when I saw the results too! Oh, girl, ME TOO. I've been wanting to reread them for years. All 12 of the books, actually! I think it'd be cool to read them all at once and get a sweeping sense of the entire plot.

  6. Abbey Stellingwerff

    This was great!! I love the Gandalf quotes! And congratulations to Professor Hamilton. I'm not familiar with his character, but I will shake his hand and clink his glass at the Silmarillion Awards after party. 😀

    • admin

      Thank you, Abbey! Professor Hamilton thanks you as well, I'm sure. 🙂 I can't recommend his books (Dragons in Our Midst) highly enough! Ooh, are you sure we want to have an after party? Those henchmen and villains might cause a disaster… XD

  7. Deborah O'Carroll

    Wow, how awesome! I'm impressed. 😀 Impressed that dear Professor Hamilton won, and impressed at your superior posting skills! (And Gandalf's of course. ;)) Awesome post! Congrats to the Prof! 😀

    • admin

      D'aww, thank you, Deborah! <3 (Gandalf thinks it's only natural that you're impressed. Professor Hamilton gratefully accepts your compliment. XD)

  8. E. E. Rawls

    Fantastic post! Congrats to the Professor for winning, and well done Gandalf on presenting the award. 🙂 I now have even more reason to start reading Dragons in Our Midst.

  9. Anonymous

    Bravo!!! Well done Tracey and Gandalf, and CONGRATS to Professor Hamilton! It's been a long time since I read his books, but I did love them when I did! Maybe I should re-read… Hmm. Loved the quote too!

    I've had an epic time with the Silmarillion Awards, thanks so much for the epic post. ^__^ Very well written!

    (Also I loved how you mentioned Gandalf the cat–I'd forgotten about him till then, but it was so appropriate!! 😀 )

    (Side note: I right clicked "Silmarillion" 'cause it had squiggly red lines (somehow thinking it was a 'real' word?) and it gave me "millionairess". XD Heehee. )

    Anyway, I loved this Tracey!!! Very well written! 🙂

    <3
    -Rebekah

    • admin

      Thanks, Rebekah! Gandalf would say thanks as well, but he just left. Something about recruiting people for yet another adventure… *shakes head* My copies of Dragons in Our Midst are sitting oh-so-patiently on my shelf, waiting for a reread too. 🙂

      I'm so glad to hear that! Thank you! ^_^ It's been a blast, and the main reason is every single one of you who has commented and participated throughout. <3

      (LOL, I couldn't go without bringing him up!)

      (Haha, Millionairess Awards it is, then. XD I'm sure the Silmarils would be worth millions…)

      I'm happy to hear that! Thanks again! 😀

  10. Mary Horton

    ACK. I literally squealed when I saw Professor Hamilton won!! I was really hoping he would. 😀

    Okay, but can I just say this post is frabjous?! BECAUSE IT IS. I loved all the Gandalf quotes, the flashback, and of course the CAT. I cracked up as soon as I got to that part. XDDD #perfection

    This post was AMAZING, and I'm so stoked about these awards! Congrats again to the Prof for winning!

    • admin

      That was my reaction when I got the email with the results! 😀

      Oh my goodness, thank you! <3 (Confession: I may have looked up most of the Gandalf quotes…) Gotta love that cat! He's been through a lot. XD

      I'm so excited to see who wins in all the other categories! This is going to be good. Prof extends his thanks, I'm sure!

  11. Zachary Totah

    Great post, Tracey! I loved how you included those Gandalf quotes. Bravo!

    I haven't read any of Bryan Davis' books yet, but from what I could tell by your post, Professor Hamilton is certainly deserving of the award.

    • admin

      Thanks, Zac! I had fun weaving them in.

      Oh, you should definitely check them out! Dragons in Our Midst ( and its two sequel series) are some of his most popular books, but ALL of his books are amazing fantasies. If you want recommendations, I've got 'em. XD

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *